New York City is once again officially home to the best bagel.
A Manhattan institution, Ess-a-Bagel took the top honors at the 2026 New York BagelFest at CitiField on Sunday. While the bagel shop had won other categories at the festival before, this marked the first time it won gold in the blind-tasted best bagel competition, knocking last year’s winner, Dallas’ Starship Bagel, to silver.
“Bagel makers from around the world keep pushing the limits of flavor, fermentation, and creativity,” festival founder Sam Silverman said in a statement. “But New Yorkers can still say, with confidence, that this is the home of the best bagels for another year. For now.”
Advertisement
Advertisement
It’s a fitting honor for the shop that is celebrating its 50th anniversary since Florence and Gene Wilpon, and Florence’s brother Aaron Wenzelberg, opened the first location in New York City’s Gramercy Park neighborhood. Since then, they have turned their roots as an Austrian baking family into four Manhattan locations, plus one in Brooklyn’s Time Out Market and another in Newark Liberty International Airport’s (EWR) Terminal A.
Ess-a-Bagel also won the title of the best New York-style bagels.
“I was shocked,” owner Beverly Wilpon said in the statement. “We know we’re a good bagel. We’re 50 years in business, and what an accomplishment in New York City, right?”
Second-place Starship Bagel may be Texas-based, but its founder also has New York roots. The shop, established by Brooklyn-born Oren Salomon, also took second place in the New York-style bagel category, but scored first place in the best sandwich category for its Chicago-style lox dog with rolled Acme nova lox and Chicago hot dog toppings atop a poppy seed bagel bun.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Other standouts included Rise Bagels from Irvine, California, which took gold in the people’s choice, best beyond the boroughs, and rising star categories. The latter category was established for bagel shops that opened their first location within the last two years.
Bagels have become an icon in New York City, but their origins actually trace back to Poland, believed to have been invented between the 13th and 17th centuries, according to the Institute of Culinary Education.
So of course, there’s also a category for international bagels, with winners coming from three different countries: Bagel Brigade from Hyderabad, India, won gold; followed by Bodega Bagels in Belfast, Ireland, with silver; and SISI Bagel in Madrid, Spain, taking bronze. Also honored was Montreal’s famed St-Viateur Bagel, the only winner in the best Montreal-style category.
Silverman started BagelFest in 2019 as a gathering of bagel enthusiasts in the Bushwick neighborhood of Brooklyn. Now, it has grown into a global celebration, having launched BagelFest West this past spring with 15 bagel shops from Seattle to Colorado. There, Rise Bagels won the inaugural best of the West honor, while Seattle’s Hey Bagel took the best bagel category (and also won best sourdough on Sunday).
Advertisement
Advertisement
For the Breadhead Awards categories—best bagel, New York-style, sourdough, and Montreal-style—a panel of judges evaluates each bagel through blind tastings of plain, unsliced samples, considering flavor, texture, appearance, and aroma.
Despite its newfound honor, Ess-a-Bagel remains true to being just a local neighborhood shop. “It’s nice to be part of the community, and it’s nice to be a small business in New York City,” Wilpon said.
Read the original article on Travel & Leisure




