Guts have become a source of immense fascination. Social media influencers promote unproven supplements said to boost gut health, whilst milk and kombucha brands promise to nourish them with “good bacteria”.
Some have dismissed the gut-obsession as a passing fad – however many doctors think that our gut microbiome might affect a whole spectrum of things, from mental health to the likelihood of getting certain cancers.
But there’s another medical possibility that I’m particularly interested in: how our gut impacts how well (or badly) we age.
Which is why, a few months ago, I found myself at St Mary’s Hospital in London, famous for the discovery of penicillin, preparing to receive a nerve-wracking insight into my own gut health.
I was there to meet Dr James Kinross. He’s a professor in surgery at Imperial College London and a practising colorectal surgeon – but perhaps the most colourful part of his job is that he analyses people’s poo.
Now that I’m in my 60s and recently became a grandparent, it seems a good time to find out what my own gut tells me about how I will fare in coming decades, says Hugh Pym (pictured with green juice as part of his food plan recommended by a dietician) [BBC]
Weeks earlier, I’d sent my own stool sample to a laboratory. Tests like these can provide insights into our gut microbiome – the trillions of microbes that live inside our stomach (including mostly bacteria, but also viruses and funghi).
“I’m a microbiome evangelist,” he says. “[It’s] is so deeply ingrained in all aspects of our health.”
He believes the gut may play a crucial role in the ageing process – with consequences for how long we live, and how physically strong we remain in our elderly years.
Some experts think that the importance of the gut microbiome in the ageing process has been overhyped, and everyone I speak to thinks that more research is needed.
Now that I am in my 60s and recently became a grandparent, it seems a good time to find out what my own gut tells me about how I will fare in coming decades.
And the answer to the bigger question: if gut health really can affect ageing, what, if anything, can we do to improve it?
The 117-year-old woman and her daily yoghurt
Maria Branyas Morera was the world’s oldest person. After she died in 2024 in northern Spain, aged 117, scientists took samples from her stool, blood, saliva, and urine and compared them with 75 other women from the Iberian peninsula.
They said that she enjoyed a broadly healthy lifestyle: she lived in the countryside, walked one hour a day, and ate an oil-rich Mediterranean diet.
But what really set her apart was the fact that each day she ate three servings of yoghurt.
Dr Manel Esteller, a geneticist at the University of Barcelona who co-wrote the study, thinks that Morera’s yoghurt habit may have given her a high level of helpful bacteria that can reduce inflammation.
“She had cells that seemed younger than her age,” Esteller says.
There have been other studies of centenarians – the superheroes of the longevity world.
Again and again, scientists have looked inside the guts of this blessed population of over-100s and found an impressive array of bacteria.
In another study, published in 2022 in a journal, Nature, researchers in Jiaoling County, southeastern China, took stool samples from 18 centenarians – and found a high diversity of bacteria when compared to younger adults.
Guts should be ‘diverse like a garden’
This makes sense to Dr Mary Ni Lochlainn, a clinical lecturer in geriatric medicine at King’s College London. She says it’s helpful to think of our gut microbiome like a garden: we want it to be as diverse as possible.
“If you go into a garden where there’s no plants and it just looks barren, that’s a low-diversity garden,” she explains. “What you want is lots of flowers, colour, seeds.”
The trouble is, as we get older the diversity of our microbiome drops significantly. Some of the helpful bacteria disappear from our guts.
But elderly people who buck this trend – and who hold on to their good bacteria well through their eighties and nineties – have been shown to live longer, healthier lives.
For Ni Lochlainn, those studies are proof of a link between our gut and ageing. “We know that centenarians… have more diverse microbiome.”
Our national interest in gut health started in earnest in the early 2000s, when new technology allowed scientists to study our internal microbes in better detail. In recent years, scientists have become particularly curious about the role in ageing that gut bacteria plays [Getty Images]
“There’s something about those people who are kind of superior beings, in a way. They’ve managed to keep their diversity.”
And it’s not just about how long someone lives – it’s also about how well they live during their later years. Kinross says there is a link between gut bacteria and frailty, or an elderly person’s ability to bounce back from an illness or injury.
My real age vs my gut’s age
Back in the lab at St Mary’s Hospital, Kinross announces his verdict: I have good “gut diversity in the microbiome”. It is “broadly healthy” which is good news. But from his tone I detect some caveats.
Duly they come. First, he explains there are a couple of “players in the gut” which might increase the risk of cardiovascular disease. Rather alarmingly, some nasty bugs are found too. E.coli and C-Difficile are present, which is not unusual. (Antibiotic use or a previous bout of gastroenteritis might have caused that.)
But then we get to the age question.
Kinross tells me that my gut biome is roughly equivalent to an Italian man five years older than me. He’s worked this out by comparing my results to a study of 62 people in northern Italy.
In that study – the only one of its kind – researchers analysed stool samples from people of different ages, ranging from 22 to 109, allowing them to paint a profile for what a person’s gut looks like at different stages of life.
A scientist compared Hugh Pym’s gut results to those of people living in the Emilia-Romagna region of northern Italy, parts of which are known for their fresh air [Universal Image Group / Getty]
The verdict makes me reflect, with a pang of guilt, about those years of ready meals and snacking.
Intense work schedules covering the 2008 banking crisis and the Covid-19 pandemic resulted in too many cakes and treats grabbed on the hoof. Living in London on and off since my mid-20s meant living with traffic fumes, rather than the fresher air of northern Italy. No wonder my gut is deemed five years older than I am.
Kinross must have seen the colour draining from my panicked face because immediately he reassures me that the Italian men may have all been on Mediterranean diets, or living in rural areas unspoiled by urban pollution.
Plus, it was a small sample size.
He reassures me further by saying “all the machinery for healthy ageing” is there and just needs to be optimised. In other words, if I get to grips with my diet, there is time for improvement.
Can you hack your gut health?
As to whether people really can improve their ageing process via their diet, Esteller is optimistic.
He stresses some “uncertainty” remains about the link between gut health and ageing, but says the evidence is now fairly clear that what we put on our plate can affect both our “morbidity and our mortality”.
In other words, how long we live, and how likely we are to remain in strong health during our senior years. “Even in the same city, [among] people with high income, people who eat better live longer,” he says.
He recommends eating olive oil, which contains bacteria-boosting polyphenols; and bluefish meat, a sharp-toothed marine food that contains fatty acids and is popular in Japan, which enjoys one of the highest life expectancies in the world (84.5), according to the World Health Organisation.
Bluefish is hard to come by in most UK supermarkets, though; it tends to be found only in specialised fishmongers or restaurants.
Bluefish is a popular food in Japan but is harder to find in the UK [Getty Images]
He also recommends avoiding refined white sugars and ultra-processed foods where possible, which can damage the diversity of bacteria in our gut.
But Esteller points out that some people will have better luck than others trying to “hack” their gut – and genes play a part.
Kinross cautions that research on how the microbiome works in different population groups is in its infancy. For now, he says, each patient should be assessed individually.
The ‘tipping point’ for older people
Armed with the report, I arrange an appointment with Raquel Britzke, a dietician, who reviews the findings and writes a menu plan designed to boost the diversity of my gut bacteria in hope that it will help me to age better.
Her plan is tailored to my own results. For the first few days of the week she suggests I make a breakfast bowl of flax seeds, chia seeds, kefir, blueberries, kiwi or pomegranate. (This isn’t a million miles from my normal bowl of low-sugar granola and yoghurt.)
For lunch, she recommends I have green salad, beans or lentils, broccoli, asparagus or beetroot, and grilled chicken without skin. This feels a bit trickier – the ingredients aren’t always easy to find when grabbing a quick bite between news assignments. And for the evening meal, it’s salmon, asparagus and brown rice.
With a raised eyebrow my wife casts doubt on my ability to stick to that every evening.
Hugh’s new diet includes juices made from kiwi, apple, kale, and mint leaves [BBC]
As for drinks, I’m recommended juices. On day one, I diligently blend some mint, apple, kiwi, kale, lemon juice, sunflower seeds and water) to make a green juice. But the mint flavour ends up crowding out the others.
Kefir and kombucha (bacteria-rich, fermented drinks) are also recommended and go down better. Both now have their place in my fridge.
Raquel Britzke also recommends I take some capsules with probiotics like Omega-3 and Vitamin D3. They don’t come cheap and it’s hard to remember the specific times of the day when they should be taken (some but not all on an empty stomach).
More from InDepth
Kinross tells me that nutritional change needs to be “significant” to make a difference to ageing.
If I rigorously follow my new diet plan, he says, I could see a change to my gut biome “within a few weeks”, he explains.
But he warns that more “modest” changes to diets – for example, if you do it one day and not the next – then the biome won’t see much benefit. And by extension, any improvement to ageing prospects are less likely too.
I still have time, he tells me. But there does come a “tipping point” for older people when the gut biome gets worse.
The chicken-and-egg of gut health
There’s another conundrum, though – one that Ni Lochlainn calls the “chicken or the egg” problem. That is: does a more diverse gut make us stronger in old age, or does the fact we’re stronger in old age mean we have a more diverse gut?
Historically it’s been difficult to know which is causing the other.
But even that question may have now been answered, thanks in part to faecal transplant research – where faeces are taken from a human or animal and given to an animal (usually a mouse) via a capsule or a tube into their stomach.
In one such study, published in 2020, scientists in the US looked at two groups of 11, healthy mice. The first group received faeces from old mice; the second group got them from young mice.
Within three months, the mice that received old faeces started to exhibit depressive-like behaviour. Their short-term memory deteriorated, as did their spatial awareness.
In effect, their bodies became older.
Ni Lochlainn accepts that to many people this sounds unpleasant – but these studies are important because they suggest a direct line of causation: from a gut microbiome to the age of a body.
Hugh Pym: ‘I found myself at St Mary’s Hospital in London preparing to receive a nerve-wracking insight into my gut health’ [Getty Images]
Not everyone is as excited about the power of our gut to control ageing. Prof Kamila Hawthorne, chair of the Royal College of GPs, says research into the gut microbiome is “exciting” and “has certainly piqued the public’s interest” – but, she adds “it’s important to remember, especially as research in the area is still emerging, that ‘gut health’ is likely just one piece of a much bigger picture.
“Good health is not determined by any single factor.”
Ultimately, scientists say it is possible to improve ageing process via your diet – though they caution that food is not everything.
Esteller estimates that diet probably determines about one-third of your ageing outcome. The rest is a mix of genetics and other lifestyle factors, such as exercise and avoiding smoking cigarettes.
As for my own gut health, it’s still early days on my new diet.
My appetite is sated and I am not tempted by snacks, other than the recommended apples, grapes and nuts. But in a busy lifestyle with unpredictable hours, sticking to this sort of meticulous plan will be challenging – and I’m doubtful of my ability to pull it off.
Still, the tests and journey has been a wake-up call on my own gut – and my future health.
Additional reporting: Luke Mintz
Top image credit: Getty Images
[BBC]
BBC InDepth is the home on the website and app for the best analysis, with fresh perspectives that challenge assumptions and deep reporting on the biggest issues of the day. Emma Barnett and John Simpson bring their pick of the most thought-provoking deep reads and analysis, every Saturday. Sign up for the newsletter here