A surgeon looks at a postoperative X-ray and sees a successful correction. The patient looks at the weeks ahead and wonders: How much pain will I have? Can I walk? Who will help me? When will my life feel normal again?
Our definition of surgical success should answer those questions.
Correcting anatomy is essential. But the experience of getting back to everyday life deserves equal attention. Pain, mobility, independence, and lasting function should be central measures of the result we achieve.
Advertisement
Advertisement
After more than three decades of performing bunion surgery, I believe the conversation before an operation should give recovery the same attention we give the operation itself.
A recent follow-up visit with a patient named Stanford illustrated why.
Twelve days after his surgery, he reported no pain. We reviewed his X-rays and the improved alignment of his foot. During our conversation, he explained how he had approached choosing a surgeon. Stanford was analytical. He questioned the procedure and researched his options, watching at least 30 patient videos. He wanted to see what people had actually experienced: how their feet looked, what their X-rays showed, and how they described their recovery.
At his visit, he said his own experience matched the positive accounts he had watched. His early progress was encouraging. It also illustrated the value of giving patients access to information that helps them understand life after surgery.

Stock image of a female doctor talking to a patient.
Understanding Recovery
There is an inevitable burden patients carry home as recovery reaches into nearly every part of their day.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Getting out of bed, preparing a meal, taking a shower, or managing stairs can become planning exercises when mobility is restricted. Time away from work can affect income. Dependence on family members can rearrange an entire household.
These consequences belong in the discussion of surgical outcomes. A technically satisfactory correction does not, by itself, describe what an operation has required of the person undergoing it.
Patients deserve to know what recovery may involve before committing to surgery. That means discussing expected pain, medication needs, restrictions, assistance at home, and the likely course of returning to ordinary activities. Uncertainty and individual differences should be part of that discussion, too, because realistic expectations require specific information.
Choosing a Surgeon
Look at the surgeon’s results. Patients researching bunion surgery encounter procedure names, devices, and claims about new techniques. Understanding the proposed operation matters, but its name cannot tell the whole story.
Advertisement
Advertisement
The surgeon’s judgment and execution matter alongside the technique. Patient selection, planning, technical decisions, and postoperative management all contribute to the outcome. For that reason, I encourage patients to examine the treating surgeon’s documented results and, when possible, speak with previous patients.
Ask what recovery was like. Ask how much help they needed. Ask whether their experience matched what they had been told.
Another patient’s experience cannot predict your own with certainty. But hearing those experiences can help you identify questions that a technical description may leave unanswered.
Measuring Patient Outcomes
It’s also imperative to measure what patients experience. For decades, I have collected written patient evaluations and video accounts of recovery. I want patients to describe their experiences in their own words.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Photographs and X-rays document important aspects of correction. Patient accounts add another dimension: comfort, confidence, independence, and the ability to participate in daily life.
That documentation becomes more useful when it is collected consistently, with attention to difficult recoveries as well as favorable ones. Testimonials offer individual perspectives; systematic follow-up helps establish how frequently particular outcomes occur.
We should track pain, medication use, mobility, return to activities, complications, and satisfaction alongside clinical findings.
We must also follow results over time. Stanford’s 12-day experience describes an early stage of recovery. Lasting correction, healing, joint function, and any need for additional treatment remain essential to judging success.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Over the course of my career, I’ve found that innovation should be evaluated by what it delivers for patients. In developing and refining my approach to bunion surgery, my priorities have included the correction itself and the experience of recovering from it.
Preserving function and reducing the burden of recovery are goals worth pursuing together. A new technique should face practical questions: Does it improve outcomes? Does it make recovery more manageable? Does it provide a durable benefit? What trade-offs does it introduce?
Novelty alone cannot answer those questions. Documented patient results can help.
Ultimately, surgical success must encompass both the result and the journey required to reach it. Before surgery, we should ask what patients want to regain. After surgery, we should ask whether they regained it, how long it took, and what they endured along the way.
Advertisement
Advertisement
A well-aligned foot matters. So does the person standing on it.
Dr. Richard Moy, DPM, is a podiatrist and foot and ankle surgeon based in Lake Forest, Southern California, who developed his bunion-correction approach in 1992 and has practiced for over 35 years across more than 10,000 bunion procedures. The views expressed in this article are the author’s own.
Related Articles
Start your unlimited Newsweek trial




