Here’s a conversation starter: Joshua Henry and Julia Harriman are off-Broadway’s answer to Matt Damon and Ben Affleck.
Next year marks three decades since those Boston boys wrote their way off Hollywood’s B-list with 1997’s Good Will Hunting, which shot to the top of the box-office charts and tied with L.A. Confidential for the second-most-nominated film status at the 70th Academy Awards — the same ceremony that saw James Cameron crowned the King of the World.
More from Gold Derby
But Affleck and Damon liked their Oscar apples, scoring two wins for Best Original Screenplay and Best Supporting Actor for Robin Williams. Over the past 30 years, Good Will Hunting has become the touchstone for actors who decide that, rather than wait around for the parts they want, they’re going to write those parts for themselves.
That brings us up to the present day and to The Conversation, a new musical that Henry and Harriman have been writing together for the past few years. “We thought about what fits our voices like a glove, and then said, ‘Let’s write it,'” Henry tells Gold Derby about the 17 tunes that he and his collaborator and co-star wrote for the show.
Asked which of them is the Affleck and which is the Damon, Henry eagerly claimed Argo status. “I think I’m the Ben,” boasts the Tony-winning star of last season’s Broadway smash, Ragtime. That means Harriman — who played Eliza in the national touring production of Hamilton — would have to get into fighting shape to fully embody The Odyssey star. “I’m not mad at it,” she says, laughing.
Now in previews at the Astor Place Theatre — opening night is scheduled for Dec. 7 — The Conversation is a song-filled portrait of a relationship in crisis. When they first met, Marcus (Henry) and Elle (Harriman) enjoyed the kind of whirlwind courtship that young lovers dream about. But now that they’ve been coupled up for a lengthy stretch, the cracks are starting to show. At a recent press event, the duo performed a suite of songs that trace the arc of the couple’s romance, including “Lost ID,” “Easy,” and “Next Thing You Know.”
“Lost ID” was the first song that made the final cut for The Conversation‘s set list, but it wasn’t the first song that the two wrote together. “The very first song we wrote isn’t in the show, but it started the whole idea for the musical,” shares Harriman. “But the bridge from that song found its way into one of the songs that did make it in.”
“That dropped song was called ‘Wake Up,’ and it was about someone waking up and not knowing if it was them who had woken up or another person,” adds Henry. “That got us thinking about what it means to have that kind of moment where you don’t know who you are, and that took us down the path to ‘Lost ID.'”
While the duo was finding their way through The Conversation, Henry found himself taking center stage in Ragtime, last season’s biggest musical revival at the Broadway box office and at the Tony Awards, where it won four statuettes. Besides Henry’s win for Best Actor in a Musical, the final tally included Best Actress in a Musical for Caissie Levy, Best Sound Design for a Musical, and Best Musical Revival in a close competition with Cats: The Jellicle Ball.
“After Ragtime, I could have done another big show,” Henry admits. “But I had to slow down and think, ‘What are you trying to put out into the world?’ And Julia and I happened to be working on this thing that had become the most important thing to me even before Ragtime ended. So I decided it was the perfect time to get out of those 1,000-seat theaters and go to a 200-seat off-Broadway space where I could show a whole different side of my voice.”
Henry’s desire to go small after going big synced up with The Conversation director Kenny Leon’s own interest in a two-person show after overseeing the 10 actors populating The Balusters, the David Lindsay-Abaire comedy that he helmed last season. “I needed a break from that,” he tells us. “More than anything, I liked working with these two artists. My job as a director every time out is to let it happen, not make it happen. I’m always trying to get the director to disappear.”
While many current Broadway musicals — including The Lost Boys and Wanted — offer plenty of stage spectacle, the more confined off-Broadway setting puts the focus on emotional spectacle, a term that Leon immediately embraces. “That’s now the name of my memoir,” he says with a grin.
“It really is a roller-coaster of emotions,” agrees Harriman. “The ups, the downs, the messy, the beautiful, the fun — just everything.” Henry quickly chimes in to say that The Conversation presents the side of relationships that “people don’t see.”
“It’s not on Instagram, it’s not in pictures — it’s the conversations you have behind the closed doors,” he adds. “Seeing it in a 278-seat theater, you’re gonna really get that feeling that you’re going to be witnessing something that should not be witnessing. Zeroing in on the intimacy of that relationship feels so, so special.”
Naturally, off-Broadway can offer a path to Broadway, and The Conversation producers Mandy Hackett and Jenny Steingart aren’t ruling out a transfer — although most likely not this spring, considering a stacked lineup of original musicals that will include Lin-Manuel Miranda’s Warriors, the U.K. hit Paddington: The Musical, and Jordan Fisher donning Prince’s vintage garb in Purple Rain. “We hope the show has a big, beautiful life,” Hackett says. “We definitely believe it has a wider reacher, and we want it to reach as many people as possible.”
“It is clearly resonating for people, because there’s a universality to the story we’re telling,” notes Steingart. “It’s been exciting to watch other people witnessing this couple working through all of their drama.”
So what do the off-Broadway Affleck and Damon think? “This could go to Broadway,” Henry allows. “We got to off-Broadway by dreaming big, and we hope that the show resonates with people. If this goes to Broadway that would be incredible, and I’m not shy about putting that out there.”
“But just for some perspective, when we were writing this, we thought it might just be an album,” Harriman notes. “Or maybe it was a concert that we’d perform at little places. From here, anything and everything is welcome and possible.”
In other words, expect them to keep The Conversation going.
Best of Gold Derby
Sign up for Gold Derby’s Newsletter. For the latest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.
Click here to read the full article.




