





Kitchn and Yahoo may earn commission from links in this article. Pricing and availability are subject to change.

Black Friday Deal
Get 40% off your first order, up to $25. Offer ends December 29, 2026.
I first tried Misfits Market back when I was in college years ago, and I loved it then. Since its launch in 2018, the online grocery delivery service has sold surplus and “misfit” foods that are safe to eat but might not meet traditional retail standards (scuffed potatoes and bruised apples). Using this model, Misfits can offer all kinds of groceries at a pretty good discount.
In the years since, Misfits Market acquired Imperfect Foods, which widened its offerings beyond produce to include essentially everything you’d find at a typical grocery store: fresh organic fruits and vegetables, meat and seafood, dairy products, eggs, prepared foods, snacks, pantry staples, wine, and even bakery items. I was curious to see if the service was still as good as I remember, so I spent a month grocery shopping only at Misfits Market. Here’s how it compares with the best online grocery services and grocery shopping in general.
What’s so great
You don’t need to have a membership
Large selection of high-quality groceries, including private-label items
Good to know
Non-members pay a delivery fee on all orders
Delivery date is determined by your location
Revolving items each week
What Is Misfits Market?
Misfits Market is an online grocery delivery service with a soft spot for the oddballs of the food world. Its selection includes a variety of surplus and “misfit” items that might otherwise be tossed aside because they contain minor blemishes or slight discoloring. It also sells items nearing their “Best-By” dates, hyper-seasonal finds, excess inventory, and products affected by packaging changes or errors, like Halloween candy in November.
The grocer delivers to all lower 48 states. You can check here to see if your location is on the list.

How to Get Started with Misfits Market
Like most online delivery services, you’ll need to create an account with an email address to use Misfits Market. There are no required membership fees. Instead, customers can choose between two options: a grocery subscription or Flex Plan.
The grocery subscription delivers a customizable box each week, with the option to skip deliveries at any time.
The Flex Plan allows customers to shop whenever they choose, whether weekly, monthly, or less often.
Deliveries arrive on a set day each week, determined by location. Ahead of that date, shoppers are given a three-day window to select their items. Those who prefer a surprise can let Misfits Market curate the box instead (which is fun!). The service suggests items based on past orders, although customers can edit or remove selections before checkout.
How Much Does Misfits Market Cost?
The cost really depends on what you get. Overall, Misfits Market’s pricing is comparable to most grocery stores, but it also prioritizes organic produce, which can often come with a hefty price tag. I’ve found that those items on Misfits Market are consistently $1 to $2 cheaper than their organic counterparts in stores.
There is a $15 minimum per order, which I’ve never had a problem reaching, although the exact dollar minimum may vary based on where you are located. You can see the price of items as you shop, so there are no surprises, and you can curate a cart based on your personal preferences. The shipping for basic orders is $5.99, and there’s a $1.99 operation fee, plus taxes and a delivery tip (always tip!).
While you don’t have to pay a membership fee, there is a Misfits+ option. For $69 per year, customers can have access to free shipping on every order, exclusive deals, and steeper discounts on Odds & Ends (Misfits Market’s private label). You’ll also fund meals for people facing food insecurity through its partnership with Feeding America.
Over the four weeks testing the service, I ordered items that mimicked what I typically buy and ended up spending $318.99 for the month.

Is Misfits Market Worth It? My Honest Review
My first thought when browsing Misfits Market all these years later was, Wow, there is incredible variety. While the options aren’t as expansive as what you’d find on, say, Instacart or Amazon Grocery, I found plenty of staples and new items, too.
The company is open to customer suggestions, too. Misfits started carrying bananas after customers requested they be added to the produce selection last year, and also recently added a section for frozen items.
Everything is sorted by categories, like produce, meat and seafood, dairy, snacks, and home goods. As I scrolled through, I also noticed a small sale section, which, you guessed it, has various last-chance and discounted items from every section of the site. In general, though, prices were either on par with or cheaper than what I see in stores.

What I Ordered from Misfits Market
After familiarizing myself with the website, I sat down Wednesday morning when my shopping window opened (it varies depending on region) and ordered my first grocery haul. Over the next three weeks, I continued ordering items that mimicked what I typically buy. Here’s everything I received over the four-week period.
Pantry: Corn tortillas, English muffins, sourdough bread, black beans, chickpeas, tinned fish, coconut milk, gummy candy, and popcorn
Eggs and dairy: Cage-free eggs, salted butter, Greek yogurt, mozzarella, Parmesan, and cream cheese
Produce: Bell peppers, sweet potatoes, kale, squash, carrots, sweet peas, grapes, avocados, cilantro, green onions, bananas, and limes
Meat and seafood: Ground beef, chorizo, sirloin steak, shrimp, andouille sausage, and chicken breasts
Miscellaneous: Parchment paper, dish soap
How Do Misfits Market Boxes Arrive?
I scheduled my delivery for Monday morning (the first slot available), and received email updates and tracking. My groceries arrived on time, completely intact, and expertly sorted. The cold groceries were with other cold items, produce was kept together, and pantry staples were packed in their own respective bags.

How I Used Misfits Market Groceries for a Month
I ordered an assortment of groceries that I already use, like Cento Chickpeas and Butcher’s Bone Broth, but for the most part I tried as many Odds & Ends items as possible. They were all things that I was already familiar with, like Greek yogurt and salted butter.
Throughout my four weeks of ordering and eating Misfits Markets’ groceries, I was thoroughly impressed with the quality of produce. I couldn’t tell what blemishes or aesthetic issues caused it to end up in Misfits Market in the first place. I never received a bruised or scratched apple, carrot, or squash (among many other produce items). Not even droopy, wet greens! What a feat.
The first morning I received my groceries, I made sourdough toast with a schmear of softened Odds & Ends Salted Butter and Odds & Ends Organic Large Pasture-Raised Eggs. The yolks were bright orange (stunning!). The butter was salty and creamy, and the sourdough slice was plush on the inside and toasted beautifully.

I continued on with my day and made chorizo tacos with Niman Ranch Pork Chorizo and Vista Hermosa Corn Tortillas with a bit of cilantro and a dollop of the Odds & Ends Greek Yogurt. It, like my breakfast, was full of flavor and every ingredient tasted fresh and bright.
My dinner that night was a bowl of taco soup that I made with Odds & Ends Mexican 4 Cheese, Heyday Canning Black Beans, Butcher’s Bone Broth, Odds & Ends Greek Yogurt, and plenty of lime. I was delighted by how seamlessly these ingredients blended into my daily routine, and how delicious the soup tasted.
My meals over the next few weeks kept that same kind of flexibility as I continued to try different groceries. One night, I wanted to test the quality of the steak, so I made a Get Thousands Grass-Fed Ribeye Wedge Cut Steak with spectacular marbling. The meat was wonderfully juicy.
Another night I made rich pantry brownies with the Odds & Ends Salted Butter. I go through a lot of butter, so it was in my weekly cart. I made grain bowls, snacking plates, salad, tacos, and much more throughout the month.
There are new items each week, which, as someone who favors diversity over consistency in my meals, I like about the platform. It’s been a fun way to stick to what I know I like, and also try new things, like Rotten Gummy Worms. Consider me a convert.
How Skipping and Cancelling Went
Skipping and cancelling a Misfits Market subscription is straightforward. If you have a flex account (which means that you do not pay for a subscription) then no skipping is required. Orders are not charged (or created) unless you add items to your cart during your designated shopping window. This is how I “cancelled” and stopped using the service.
With a subscription, though, it takes an extra stop. Log into your account, click on the Upcoming Deliveries page in the account menu, and skip or cancel from there.
How Did Misfits Market Measure Up?
What’s Changed in 2026
Misfits Market now has frozen foods that you can add to your orders. Frozen items come in their own designated box, and there is a $30 minimum on frozen food orders. I also updated the costs of the box, how boxes arrive in the mail, and canceling information.
Should YOU Try Misfits Market?
Yes if you are a shopper who frequently buys organic produce or shops for a small household, then Misfits Market can be especially practical. If you’re someone who likes consistency and the flexibility to shop any day of the week, it might not be your ideal platform. Maybe try something with more options like Amazon Fresh. (I should know; I tried Amazon Fresh for a month, too.)
I plan to continue using the service. The ability to shop easily, access a wide selection, and feel confident about purchasing responsibly adds to its appeal. Plus, customers who order regularly may also benefit from a Misfits+ membership, which helps reduce shipping costs over time.
Why You Should Trust Me
I’ve tested several grocery delivery services as part of my job as a groceries editor at The Kitchn. (Reviewing groceries is also one of my passions.) I ordered a variety of groceries from Misfits Market and tested them over the course of four weeks. I also took notes on delivery, quality, and functionality of the platform. Every product in this review was eaten by me and used in my very own kitchen.
Sign up: Misfits Market
Have you tried Misfits Market? Tell us about your experience in the comments below.
Further Reading
Unlock Weekly Recipes You Won’t Find Anywhere Else
We Tried 8 Methods of Cooking Bacon and Found an Absolute Winner
The Brilliant Hack That’ll Make Storing Your Foil and Parchment Paper a Million Times Better
Sign up for The Kitchn’s Daily newsletter to receive our best recipes, posts, and shopping tips in your inbox.
Source link




