Before Something Corporate turned them into pop-punk anthems, a majority of Andrew McMahon’s songs were written alone at the piano. “Most of my songs kind of start sounding like piano ballads and only become rock songs because we throw drums on them and guitars,” the musician, 44, exclusively tells Men’s Journal.
His new EP, Strings Attached Vol. II (Something Corporate Years), revisits five of them in stripped-down form. Produced by Suzy Shinn (Weezer, Fall Out Boy) and McMahon, with string arrangements by Allie Stamler, the collection reworks “She Paints Me Blue,” “I Woke Up in a Car,” “Punk Rock Princess,” “21 and Invincible,” and “Watch the Sky,” pulled from the band’s albums Leaving Through the Window and North. “The piano that’s getting played on a lot of these songs is kind of the piano that was played as it was written,” he says. “And I think there’s something kind of fun about that, that people don’t realize.”
The EP follows last year’s Everything in Transit: Strings Attached, which marked 20 years of Jack’s Mannequin’s debut. McMahon says the whole series grew out of a bigger goal: playing with symphonies. “My desire to play symphonies came first,” he explains. “Then once we knew we were going to be celebrating 20 years of Everything in Transit, it was like, oh, this is a really cool way to honor that album by pulling off a few songs.”
He describes his process as working from “pencil sketches” in his head. “You sort of put a goal out on the horizon, and then you start trying to stitch it together so it’s coherent and feels like a part of a larger narrative,” he says.
Picking five Something Corporate songs, he admits, was “not as well thought-out of a process as you might think.” He and Shinn played through the records, and with a deep catalog of B-sides to choose from, McMahon balanced the obvious picks with songs fans have championed for years. “Obviously you want to do a couple of the big ones,” he says. “Then it was like, okay, what are songs that people have raised their hands on a bunch that maybe weren’t even the biggest songs in the catalog?”
The recording sessions were pretty loose. Shinn ran the control room while McMahon lay on a couch in the live room with Stamler, laying down a guide piano and vocal before the two experimented with how the strings could carry the rhythm and melody. “It’s a real sort of flow state kind of process, and an absolute joy,” he says. “They’re two of the most fun people to be in a studio with.”

Courtesy of Andrew McMahon
The EP opens with “She Paints Me Blue,” which McMahon re-harmonized and moved to a new key. While working on it, he started picturing it at a wedding. “If I was getting married now and I was a fan, could we give him a good first dance or a walk down the aisle kind of jam?” he says.
“I Woke Up in a Car,” the band’s road-trip anthem and a longtime set opener, remains one of his proudest songs. “I still to this day think it’s one of my best written lyrics,” he says. He wrote it after the band’s first van tours, when they loaded their own gear, crammed into hotel rooms, and played “sometimes a big show and sometimes to five people.” Today, he sees it as a reminder. “Should I get salty or tired or frustrated with this or that, it’s like, always remember, this was your dream,” he says. “Here is a snapshot of what it looked like to be at the beginning, at the gates of that thing opening up for me.”
For “Punk Rock Princess,” the strings are layered over the slower arrangement from one of Something Corporate’s earliest recordings, a version that diehard fans have known for years.
“21 and Invincible” seemingly carries the most weight for McMahon, who was diagnosed with acute lymphocytic leukemia at 22 and received a stem cell transplant from his sister in 2005. He remembers the first time he played the song after getting back on his feet, at a show marking 100 days since the transplant. “I sat down at the piano to play that song solo and was almost in tears,” he says. “You had this sort of artifact of a time when I felt very much fearless and untouchable. And then to be only 23 and sit down at a piano and realize just how hard life had knocked me on my ass.”
He now sees the song as “this linchpin between my life before being sick and my life after.” It’s a reminder, he says, “of how fearless you were at one point and how much you wish to hold on to that.”
The EP closes with “Watch the Sky,” which first appeared on the Japanese release of North and became what McMahon calls a “dark horse favorite” among fans. It’s one of his own favorites, too. He wrote it during an intense stretch while the band lived and recorded in a house he describes as “legitimately haunted.” One night, he climbed onto the roof with his bandmates to watch the sunset, which gave him the title, and he wrote the song at the studio piano the next morning. “Sometimes you can get into a pretty dark place, and it doesn’t mean that you have to live there,” he says. “If you’ve got enough hope, you can kind of navigate your way out.”
McMahon says he was nervous about how his Something Corporate bandmates would react to him revisiting the songs on his own, but “they were super sweet about it.”
The strings series may not stop here. “If we get to the Wilderness and put out five of those, and there’s still an appetite for it, it’s a really fun thing for me,” he says of his third project, Andrew McMahon in the Wilderness.
The songs are also heading to a concert hall. McMahon spoke with Men’s Journal about an hour before his first rehearsal with the Colorado Symphony, ahead of the Strings Attached show’s debut at the 17th annual Dear Jack Benefit this past weekend in Denver, which supports his nonprofit for adolescents and young adults with cancer. “I’m super nervous, to be honest,” he admitted, noting the challenge of locking in with that many musicians and “being at the helm without a drummer.” The show will also travel to Atlanta, Kansas City, St. Louis, Milwaukee, Minneapolis, and Seattle in 2027.
He’s also writing again. After his solo “An Evening with Andrew McMahon and His Piano” tour wraps Nov. 22, he heads to Nashville to keep working on a batch of new songs. “I’m trying to find enough songs that I love,” he says, “and then find a way to at least put them out there that feels soulful.”
Related: Dylan Efron on Adventure, Fitness and Finding Confidence in His 30s (Exclusive)

This story was originally published by Men’s Journal on Nov 16, 2026, where it first appeared in the Entertainment section. Add Men’s Journal as a Preferred Source by clicking here.




