Reviewed by Dietitian Jane Leverich, M.S., RDN

Credit: Getty Images. EatingWell Design.
Key Points
-
Avoid wet batters in air fryers to prevent burning, sticking and difficult cleanup.
-
Light or small foods, like leafy greens, may burn or blow around; use other ingredients to weigh them down.
-
Air fryers cook quickly with less fat, retaining nutrients and supporting heart health.
When I was a kid, I always wanted an Easy-Bake Oven. I never did get to make a tiny cake on my counter as I dreamed of, but when I bought my first air fryer, the thrill was pretty much the same. In fact, I called it my Easy-Bake Convection Oven, referring to the fact that air fryers cook by circulating hot air with a high-speed fan.
Back when I purchased my first air fryer, I wanted to use it for everything. I had plenty of successes and a few failures. If I’d spoken to an expert beforehand, I could have avoided some of those pitfalls. Now, I’ve asked two dietitians to share which five foods should never go in an air fryer, along with some of the most delicious things that are worth making in one.
1. Wet Batter
My first mistake was trying to actually fry some brined and battered chicken in my air fryer. Oops. As Gina Rancourt, M.S., RD, CD, puts it, “Anything too drippy or soggy or sitting in liquid will end up burning because of the fan blowing air around.”
Unlike deep-frying, an air fryer doesn’t submerge food in hot oil to quickly set a wet coating. Instead, the circulating air can blow loose batter around before it has a chance to cook, leaving you with a messy basket and unevenly coated food.
And don’t forget the cleanup. Part of the appeal of an air fryer is how easy it is to clean. Wet batter can drip through the basket, stick to the bottom and leave you soaking it for hours. Instead of wet batter, stick with a dry breading or use a recipe specifically designed for the air fryer.
2. Large Pieces of Meat
Many air-fryer brands advertise that you can cook a whole chicken, but be mindful of the size of your appliance and the food you’re putting inside it. If a piece of meat is too large for the basket, there may not be enough room for hot air to circulate around it. That can lead to uneven cooking.
“The outside may be cooked and crispy, but the internal temp won’t reach a safe internal temperature for eating,” warns Rancourt. Before cooking a large piece of meat, check your air fryer’s capacity and the manufacturer’s instructions. Use a meat thermometer to confirm that the thickest part of the meat has reached a safe internal temperature. If the food is crowded or doesn’t fit comfortably, choose a conventional oven instead.
3. Leafy Greens
Allison Tepper, M.S., RD, LDN, and Rancourt both point out that you could be in for a charred mess if you try to cook spinach or loose, chopped kale in your air fryer. “On their own, these foods may not cook properly and can blow around the air fryer,” says Tepper. “Try leafy greens as part of a recipe instead.”
Having had burnt baby spinach stick to the top of my air fryer, I know she speaks the truth. The lightweight leaves can get caught in the circulating air and blow toward the heating element, where they may burn. If you’re hoping to make kale chips, the conventional oven may be a better bet.
4. Popcorn
“Air fryers are not designed to pop popcorn,” Tepper warns. It may seem like a good idea to get your snack from kernel to fluffy, movie-theater treat in record time, but the fan can cause problems.
At best, many of your kernels may not pop. At worst, kernels could get blown into the heating element, potentially creating a fire hazard. If you’re looking for popcorn, the microwave could be your best friend, especially if you prefer to avoid the stovetop or a popcorn popper.
5. Cheese
One thing I love to make in the air fryer is a simple chicken Parmesan. But when I do, I’m very careful about how I apply the Italian cheese blend. When a little bit melts and burns into the basket, I can expect a whole lot of cleaning time.
That’s why cooking loose cheese on its own isn’t a great idea. It can melt through the basket, stick to the heating element or create a mess that’s tough to clean. If you want to cook with cheese in your air fryer, use a recipe that keeps it contained or places it on top of another food. For example, baked Brie in puff pastry keeps the cheese tucked inside a pastry shell.
Tips for Selecting Foods to Cook in an Air Fryer
“Air fryers allow for quick, easy and nutritious meals to be made at home and can be used with a variety of foods,” says Tepper. Here’s how to set yourself up for success:
-
Choose foods that won’t blow around. Very lightweight ingredients may get caught in the circulating air and burn. Make sure food is arranged securely in the basket.
-
Use a little oil. “A light coating of healthy fat like avocado or olive oil helps heat transfer, locks in seasonings and gets things golden and crispy,” says Rancourt.
-
Cut ingredients into similar sizes. This helps everything cook more evenly and finish around the same time. Think of it as making a quick sheet-pan dinner in your basket.
-
Don’t overcrowd the basket. Leave room for hot air to circulate around the food. Cook in batches if necessary, and follow your appliance’s instructions for loading and cooking.
Ways to Enjoy Foods Cooked in an Air Fryer
Now that you know which foods can be tricky to cook in an air fryer, what should you make? From vegetables to desserts, it’s a great way to get dinner on the table with less hands-on time.
-
Crisp up your vegetables. “I love tossing broccoli, cauliflower or green beans in the air fryer for a fast side dish with great charred edges,” says Rancourt.
-
Make homemade falafel. Tepper’s favorite thing to make in her air fryer is falafel, which is perfect for a pita sandwich or served atop a salad.
-
Turn chickpeas into a crunchy snack. Both dietitians love crisping up chickpeas in the air fryer. Rancourt tosses a can of chickpeas with garlic powder, paprika and avocado oil before cooking them for 12 to 15 minutes. Just make sure to pat them dry first!
-
Cook a quick protein. Don’t be afraid of protein, either. Tepper says that the air fryer is her favorite way to make a quick chicken dinner.
Our Expert Take
Air fryers can make it easier to prepare quick meals at home, often using less oil than traditional deep-frying. But they’re not ideal for every ingredient or recipe. Wet batter, loose leafy greens, popcorn and uncontained cheese can make a mess, while oversize cuts of meat may cook unevenly. Knowing which foods to skip and which ones work well can help you get more out of your favorite countertop appliance. And after my early mishaps, I can say that’s advice worth taking.
Add EatingWell as a preferred source on Google to see more of our stories on Google news and search results.
Read the original article on EatingWell




