If you love staying on property at Walt Disney World, buying into Disney Vacation Club can look tempting—especially when you compare the upfront cost against years of Deluxe resort room rates.
And with Disney’s Lakeshore Lodge—the brand’s latest Bay Lake DVC resort featuring nature-inspired rooms themed to Bambi, Pocahontas, and Encanto (plus standalone A-frame Lake Houses)—set to open in July 2027, a whole fresh round of temptation is right around the corner.
Yet according to Rachel Friem, a 57-year-old University of Pittsburgh communication professor and DVC creator (@genxtravelmom) who owns seven contracts totaling 1,075 points, membership is far from a slam dunk for every Disney fan.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Before you sign a contract, Friem tells Parade there are four essential questions to ask yourself first.
Related: I Tried Every Single Disney Vacation Club Perk—Here’s What Disney’s Most Exclusive Club Is Really Like
1. Are You Going to Obsess Over “Opportunity Cost”?
One of the biggest financial pushbacks against DVC is whether that upfront cash—which easily runs into the tens of thousands of dollars—would earn more sitting in the stock market. Friem says if you are the type of person who will resent tying up capital in prepaid vacations rather than chasing investment returns, skip it immediately.
“If you think about the opportunity cost of the money that you’re dumping in, don’t even go down the road,” Friem says. “If you’ve said, ‘But what about the opportunity cost?’ it’s not for you, because that mentality is not about investing in future vacations—it’s about, ‘I need to be making money with every dollar I own all the time,’ and that is a guaranteed person who should never do this.”
Advertisement
Advertisement
Related: The $99 Upgrade That Unlocks Disney World’s Quietest ‘Secret’ Lounge After Dark
2. Can You Comfortably Afford the Annual Dues—Not Just the Buy-In?
New buyers often fixate on the upfront purchase price per point, overlooking the annual maintenance dues that rise roughly 3% to 5% every year for the life of the contract. Friem, who currently budgets around $9,500 a year in dues across her contracts and intentionally bought three older contracts expiring in 2042 so her bills drop in her seventies, urges buyers to stress-test their future retirement budget first.
“It’s very important to think about the initial chunk of change that you put in is really not where your consideration should be,” Friem explains. “It’s about what you can afford with the dues.” If your income will shrink in retirement and those recurring annual bills could become a burden 10 or 15 years down the road, she warns against locking yourself in.
Related: Disney Vacation Club Announces 8 Exclusive After-Hours Parties for 2027—Here’s How to Get In
3. Would You Ever Be Willing to Resell Your Contract?
Because DVC is technically a deeded real estate timeshare, critics often warn buyers that they are stuck forever. In reality, DVC contracts hold substantial resale value—meaning you can sell them if your travel habits or budget change—provided you are emotionally open to letting them go.
Advertisement
Advertisement
“If somebody is going to be unwilling to consider selling in the future and they’re hung up on the fact that Disney is a timeshare, they should not purchase,” Friem says. “If you are willing to consider selling in the future when your dues maybe are too high for you, then I think you are a good candidate.”
Related: The Disney Vacation Club Benefits Members Say Make It Worth Every Penny
4. Do You Crave Predictability—or Brand-New Destinations?
Finally, Friem points out that DVC only makes sense if returning to Disney’s familiar resorts year after year genuinely brings you joy rather than feeling repetitive. For travelers who want every vacation to be an unpredictable adventure somewhere new, tying up travel funds in Orlando or Anaheim can feel restrictive.
“People who don’t want to tie up that money and really want to travel to unknown places, and people who are not going to be satisfied with how little Disney changes,” Friem notes, are better off paying cash as they go—leaving DVC to travelers who value having a trusted, repeatable home base they can count on for decades.
Related: Why One 57-Year-Old Caregiver Turned to Disney Trips as Her ‘Escape Hatch’ From Burnout

This story was originally published by Parade on Nov 18, 2026, where it first appeared in the Travel section. Add Parade as a Preferred Source by clicking here.




